Maui Time

  • News
    • Walk Story: Mauitime 2018 Candidate Interviews
    • Business
    • Education
    • Health
    • Law Enforcement
    • News of the Weird
    • Politics
    • Science and Environment
    • Surf & Sports
  • Eh Brah
  • Culture
    • Activities
    • Fashion
    • Health and Wellness
    • History
    • Horoscope
    • Letters
    • Maui Community
    • People
    • Wedding
  • Entertainment
    • Art
    • Calendar
    • Community Events
    • Film Critique
    • Movies & Showtimes
    • Music
    • Stage
  • Food & Drink
    • Food News
    • Maui Bars
    • Made on Maui
    • Maui Restaurants
    • Recipes
  • Best of Maui
    • Best Restaurants and Bars, Food and Drink on Maui
      • BEST BAR ON MAUI
      • BEST BARISTA ON MAUI
      • BEST BBQ ON MAUI
      • BEST BENTO ON MAUI
      • BEST DINNER ON MAUI
      • BEST KEPT SECRET ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL BREWER ON MAUI
      • BEST BREAKFAST ON MAUI
      • BEST BURGER ON MAUI
      • BEST BURRITO ON MAUI
      • BEST BUSINESS LUNCH ON MAUI
      • BEST CHEF ON MAUI
      • BEST CHINESE ON MAUI
      • BEST COCKTAIL ON MAUI
      • BEST DINING WITH A VIEW ON MAUI
      • BEST DIVE BAR ON MAUI
      • BEST FARMERS MARKET ON MAUI
      • BEST FEMALE BARTENDER ON MAUI
      • BEST FINE DINING ON MAUI
      • BEST FISH AND CHIPS ON MAUI
      • BEST FISH SANDWICHES ON MAUI
      • BEST FISH TACOS ON MAUI
      • BEST FOOD BOOTH AT FAIR ON MAUI
      • BEST FOOD TRUCK ON MAUI
      • BEST HAPPY HOUR ON MAUI
      • BEST HEALTH FOOD STORE ON MAUI
      • BEST HOSTESS BAR ON MAUI
      • BEST ITALIAN FOOD ON MAUI
      • BEST JAPANESE ON MAUI
      • BEST KID FRIENDLY ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL CHEAP EATS ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL COFFEE HOUSE ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL FARM ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL FOOD ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL FOOD PRODUCT ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL HOT DOG ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL ICE CREAM ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL LATE NIGHT FOOD ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL LIQUOR STORE ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL PIZZA ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL SANDWICH ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCALLY MADE BEVERAGE ON MAUI
      • BEST LUAU SHOW ON MAUI
      • BEST LUNCH ON MAUI
      • BEST MAI TAI ON MAUI
      • BEST MALE BARTENDER ON MAUI
      • BEST MEXICAN FOOD ON MAUI
      • BEST NEW BAR ON MAUI
      • BEST NEW RESTAURANT ON MAUI
      • BEST NOODLE SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST PANCAKES ON MAUI
      • BEST PAU HANA ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO BUY ADULT BEVERAGES ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO BUY POKE ON MAUI
      • BEST PLATE LUNCH ON MAUI
      • BEST PUPUS ON MAUI
      • BEST RESTAURANT ON MAUI
      • BEST RESTAURANT WITH KAMAAINA DEAL ON MAUI
      • BEST SAIMIN/RAMEN ON MAUI
      • BEST SEAFOOD ON MAUI
      • BEST SECRET WINE CELLAR ON MAUI
      • BEST SERVER ON MAUI
      • BEST SERVICE ON MAUI
      • BEST SHAVE ICE ON MAUI
      • BEST SMOOTHIE ON MAUI
      • BEST SPAM MUSUBI ON MAUI
      • BEST STEAK ON MAUI
      • BEST SUSHI ON MAUI
      • BEST VEGETARIAN ON MAUI
      • BEST VIETNAMESE ON MAUI
    • Best Arts Entertainment and Nightlife on Maui
      • BEST AKAKU PROGRAM ON MAUI
      • BEST BAND ON MAUI
      • BEST DINNER AND SHOW ON MAUI
      • BEST FEMALE MUSICIAN ON MAUI
      • BEST GALLERY ON MAUI
      • BEST KARAOKE ON MAUI
      • BEST LIVE THEATER ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL BLOG ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL CLUB DJ ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL COMEDIAN ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL FACEBOOK FEED ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL INSTRAGRAM ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL RADIO STATION ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL TWITTER FEED ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL VISUAL ARTIST ON MAUI
      • BEST MALE MUSICIAN ON MAUI
      • BEST MUSEUM ON MAUI
      • BEST OPEN MIC NIGHT ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO DANCE ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO SHOOT POOL ON MAUI
    • Best Businesses Goods and Services on Maui
      • BEST ADULT SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST AUTO MECHANIC ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO BUY AN UKELELE ON MAUI
      • BEST BIKE SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST BOOKSTORE ON MAUI
      • BEST BRIDAL SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST CONSIGNMENT STORE ON MAUI
      • BEST GREEN BUSINESS ON MAUI
      • BEST HARDWARE STORE ON MAUI
      • BEST HEAD SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST HOME FURNISHING ON MAUI
      • BEST HOTEL/ACCOMODATIONS ON MAUI
      • BEST JEWELRY STORE ON MAUI
      • BEST LASER HAIR REMOVAL ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL BOUTIQUE ON MAUI
      • LOCAL CLOTHING DESIGNER
      • BEST LOCAL SURF SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST MALE BARTENDER ON MAUI
      • BEST NEW BUSINESS ON MAUI
      • BEST OUT-OF-BUSINESS-BUSINESS ON MAUI
      • BEST PET SUPPLY STORE ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO BUY MUSIC ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO GET A BODYBOARD ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO GET A FACIAL ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO GET A MANICURE OR PEDICURE ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO GET KITESURF GEAR ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO GET WAXED ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO SEE WW2 MEMOROBILIA ON MAUI
      • BEST PRESCHOOL/DAYCARE ON MAUI
      • BEST RECYCLING CENTER ON MAUI
      • BEST SALON ON MAUI
      • BEST SCUBA/SNORKEL SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST SHOPPING CENTER ON MAUI
      • BEST SUP BOARD SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST SWIMWEAR SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST TATTOO SHOP ON MAUI
      • BEST WAY TO GET RID OF THE GIANT TV SITTING IN YOUR GARAGE ON MAUI
    • Best Sports and Lesiure on Maui
      • BEST ACTIVITIES COMPANY ON MAUI
      • BEST BARBECUING BEACH ON MAUI
      • BEST CHILDREN’S ACTIVITY ON MAUI
      • BEST COUNTY PARK ON MAUI
      • BEST FITNESS CLUB ON MAUI
      • BEST HIGH SCHOOL SPIRIT ON MAUI
      • BEST HIKE ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL AMATEUR SURFER ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCALS BEACH ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL COACH ON MAUI
      • BEST LOCAL GROM ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE FOR OCEAN SPORT ETHUSIASTS ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO BUY KITESURF GEAR ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO WORKOUT WITH A VIEW ON MAUI
      • BEST PLAYGROUND ON MAUI
      • BEST PUBLIC POOL ON MAUI
      • BEST SCHOLASTIC ATHLETE ON MAUI
      • BEST SNORKELING SPOT ON MAUI
      • BEST SPA ON MAUI
      • BEST SWIMMING BEACH ON MAUI
      • BEST YOGA STUDIO ON MAUI
      • BEST YOGA TEACHER ON MAUI
      • BEST GYM ON MAUI
      • BEST RESORT POOL ON MAUI
    • Best Politics and Environment on Maui
      • BEST COMMUNITY NON-PROFIT ON MAUI
      • BEST COUNTY BLUNDER ON MAUI
      • BEST COUNTY OFFICAL ON MAUI
      • BEST ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUE ON MAUI
      • BEST ENVIRONMENTAL NON-PROFIT ON MAUI
      • BEST GUBERNATORIAL CANDIDATE ON MAUI
      • BEST MAYORAL CANDIDATE ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO PAY RESPECT TO MAUI HISTORY ON MAUI
      • BEST PLACE TO SEE HAWAII AS IT WAS PRE-CONTACT ON MAUI
      • BEST POLITICAL ACTIVIST ON MAUI
      • BEST POLITICAL SCANDAL ON MAUI
      • BEST RESOURCE ON MAUI POLITICAL HISTORY ON MAUI
      • BEST SCARIEST PUBLIC FIGURE ON MAUI
      • BEST STATE BLUNDER ON MAUI
      • BEST TOWN TO LIVE IN ON MAUI
      • BEST TOWN TO VISIT ON MAUI
  • About
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Authors Page
  • Events
  • Add Your Event
  • Events by Venue
    • West Maui
    • South Maui
    • Central Maui
      • Maui Arts and Cultural Center
    • Upcountry Maui
  • How to tip Mauitime: Signal, email and US Postal
  • February 20, 2019
You are here: Home / Culture / Deadly Force: Where does Hawaii draw the line between homicide and self-defense?

Deadly Force: Where does Hawaii draw the line between homicide and self-defense?

June 14, 2012 by Anthony Pignataro Leave a Comment

By Jacob Shafer

Kill or be killed. In the jungle it’s ironclad law; in human society it’s anything but.
Yes, we condone killing in certain extreme cases—during war, as punishment for the most heinous crimes and, sometimes, in self defense. Even then, however, it comes wrapped in layers of practical and moral ambiguity.

It’s no surprise, then, that the Trayvon Martin case continues to make headlines. As you’re surely aware, Martin, an unarmed black teenager, was shot to death earlier this year in a Florida gated community by George Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer. Zimmerman claims Martin was acting suspiciously and attacked him when confronted. Martin’s family insists Trayvon did nothing wrong.

However the case plays out, it has exhumed some simmering, divisive issues—race, class, gun control—that always seem to be bubbling just below the surface of the American experiment, waiting for any excuse to erupt. And it has raised a fascinating, terrifying question: When is it acceptable to take another person’s life?

In Hawaii, like most places, the answer isn’t always clear.

*   *   *

In the wee hours of Nov. 5, 2011, 23-year-old Kollin Elderts lay bleeding to death on the floor of a Waikiki McDonald’s. The bullet in his chest came from a gun fired by 27-year-old Christopher Deedy, an off-duty federal agent.

The events leading up to the shooting remain murky. Deedy, who was charged with murder, contends that Elderts was the aggressor and that he acted in self-defense in his capacity as a law enforcement officer. But a lawsuit filed by Elderts’ family tells a different story.

According to the suit, filed less than two weeks after the incident, Deedy “initiated violence” by “kicking Kollin Elderts in the chest with a martial arts maneuver.”

The suit alleges that Deedy had been drinking that night. Deedy refused a blood alcohol test, according to a KITV report, while cocaine, marijuana and alcohol were found in Elderts’ system.
Reaction to the case has split between those defending Deedy’s actions and those painting him as yet another overzealous, reckless cop (the shooting occurred during the APEC conference, when Oahu law enforcement were on high alert). The fact that Deedy was a federal agent may give him more leeway, but how far can average Hawaii residents go to defend themselves?

Hawaii’s self-defense law, outlined in HRS 703-304, allows for the use of deadly force, “if the actor believes that deadly force is necessary to protect himself against death, serious bodily injury, kidnapping, rape, or forcible sodomy.” Hawaii’s law does not compel a person to retreat from “his dwelling or place of work” when threatened.

This is the now-infamous “stand your ground” provision—not as broad as the Florida statute currently being tested by the Trayvon Martin case, but broader than many other states. “We would not normally expect a man to abandon his home to an aggressor and would allow him to stand his ground,” reads the commentary accompanying HRS 703-304.

The law, however, has limits. In April, a judge upheld the 20-year sentence given to Kevin Metcalfe, a Hawaii Island man convicted of shooting another man, Larry Kuahuia, with a 12-gauge shotgun in 2009.

Metcalfe claimed he caught Kuahuia trying to break into his greenhouse, which was filled with marijuana plants, and that Kuahuia charged at him. But evidence contradicted Metcalfe’s account. During the trial Maui pathologist Anthony Manoukian testified that Kuahuia was shot in the back, according to the Hawaii Tribune-Herald.

In 2009—the same year Kevin Metcalfe killed Larry Kuahuia—the Hawaii legislature considered a bill that would have amended HRS 703-304, lowering the threshold of threat from “serious bodily injury, kidnapping, rape, or forcible sodomy” to mere physical attack and expanding the “stand your ground” provision to include any public place.

“In light of the increasing presence of violence in our society and the availability firearms and other deadly weapons, [this bill] would allow the public to become more secure in their homes, places of employment and other areas where they should be able to enjoy life free from dangers caused by the criminal element,” wrote the state Public Defender’s office in testimony submitted to the House Judiciary Committee.

The prosecutor’s office, meanwhile, had serious reservations. Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Douglas Chin offered the following hypothetical: “[Suppose] a driver cuts off a car containing two large men who pull into the same parking lot as the driver. The two men exit the vehicle and approach the driver yelling at the driver for cutting them off, but the driver can safely drive away from the incident. Under the current law, since the driver can retreat in complete safety, he or she must do so before using force against the two men. If this bill were to pass and the duty to retreat was eliminated, might the driver be more inclined to use deadly force if he or she feared death or serious bodily injury?”

In February, Chin’s scenario played out with eerie precision when 65-year-old Douglas Freeman fired two shots into the driver’s side of 23-year-old Bronson Botelho’s car on Oahu’s H-2 freeway. Bothelo says Freeman cut him off, then later shot at him. Freeman was charged with several counts, including reckless endangerment and terroristic threatening.

Freeman’s lawyer, Marcus Sierra, told KHON Freeman was merely defending himself.

*   *   *

Is Hawaii gun happy? According to a recent report from the state Attorney General’s office, 15,375 firearm permits were processed statewide in 2011, a 20 percent uptick compared to 2010. But overall, gun ownership in Hawaii falls well below the national average, as MauiTime noted in April after the release of the AG’s report.

Still, Hawaii boasts a vocal gun lobby. The group Hawaii Concealed Carry (tagline, “protecting paradise”) fights regularly to loosen state gun laws, issuing opinion pieces with titles like “‘Aloha’ Won’t Save Your Family.”

In the wake of the Trayvon Martin shooting, the Hawaii Rifle Association posted a commentary on its Web site that accused “race baiters” of turning the case into a “media circus.”

“President Obama has directed the Justice Department to investigate,” states the commentary. “It’s far, far too premature for DOJ to stick its nose into what is purely a state crime at this point—IF a crime was committed.”

(The commentary goes on to describe Martin as a “6 foot 2 inch football player” while noting that Zimmerman is “5 feet 9 inches in height,” with no mention of the fact that loaded weapons tend to render size disparities moot.)

That’s the same Hawaii Rifle Association whose parent organization, the NRA, advocated expanding HRS 703-304 with the following testimony: “A victim who is in fear of being attacked can’t be expected to wait before taking action to protect him or herself and loved ones and ask the criminal, ‘excuse me, intruder, are you here breaking into my home to rape me, kill me, or are you just here to beat me up and steal my stuff and oh, by the way, what kind of weapon do you have?’”

Bruce McEwan, chair of the state Injury Prevention Advisory Committee, had a different take. “A law that promotes the use of deadly force as the first line of defense can create any number of unintended consequences,” McEwan testified. Expansive self defense laws “may make the public feel safer,” he added, but “instead create a mentality of fear.”

*   *   *

Trayvon Martin is dead. So are Kollin Elderts and Larry Kuahuia. Whether their killings were justified is an open question; the finality of their deaths is not. When we give anyone—a jury, a soldier, a citizen—the right to take another’s life we must do so with the utmost caution. And when we codify that right into law, we must prepare for the inevitable consequences.

“I hope I am not for the killing,” wrote Ernest Hemingway—who ended his own life with a shotgun blast—in For Whom The Bell Tolls. “The killing is necessary, I know, but still the doing of it is very bad for a man and I think that, after all this is over and we have won the war, there must be a penance of some kind for the cleansing of us all.”

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Culture Tagged With: Christopher Deedy, guns, Hawaii, Hawaii Rifle Association, Jacob Shafer, Kollin Elderts

Comments

comments

Subscribe to Our Newsletter


Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

  • News
  • Education
  • Business
  • Health
  • Law Enforcement
  • News of the Weird
  • Politics
  • Science and Environment
  • Surf & Sports
  • Eh Brah
  • Culture
  • Activities
  • Fashion
  • Health and Wellness
  • History
  • horoscope
  • Letters
  • People
  • Wedding
  • Entertainment
  • Art
  • Calendar
  • Community Events
  • Film Critique
  • Music
  • Stage
  • Food & Drink
  • Maui Bars
  • Food News
  • Recipes
  • Maui Restaurants
  • Events
  • Add Your Event
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Authors Page

Copyright © 2019 · Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.